Economic Development Studies and Tax Abatement
Over the past few weeks, the research center in which I work published three different studies evaluating the role of economic development programs in Indiana.
The results of our work held some surprises and some not so surprising findings.
The first study evaluated the Indiana Economic Development Corporation’s suite of services. We made a number of small recommendations, suggesting, for example, that IEDC improve some website offerings, but it is clear that IEDC is offering among the most up-to-date economic development activities.
Moreover, the National Governor’s Association recently commissioned a study that strongly recommended that other states adopt the type of public-private partnership in state economic development efforts which is in use here in Indiana. IEDC employs roughly 65 persons, while several surrounding states had more than 400 workers. So, I would expect a lot more states embracing our model.
Among the more interesting findings were that IEDC had significantly grown the number of employers it works with since shifting to the public-private model. In 2004, IEDC was working with employers of roughly 1 out of every 50 new jobs that came to Indiana. By 2010 that share had grown to more than 1 out of 25.
We also found that the new employers IEDC works with are more evenly distributed across the state than are new jobs as a whole. Still, most new jobs in Indiana never connect with the economic development apparatus at the local, regional or state level, which means that economic development efforts alone won’t create prosperity.
The second study examined tax incentives in Indiana, at the state and local level. It is worth noting that to ask me and my colleague Dagney Faulk to study the issue required a great deal of political courage by IEDC. Both of us have studied and testified on tax incentives in a number of states, and some of my work helped aid the demise of Michigan’s largest incentive program in 2012.
The data we used were of actual jobs created (according to the Department of Labor), and the size of the incentive reported by the states and counties. This is important because many critiques of the job-creating effects of incentives focus on the gap between the promised and actual jobs in a business. Economists think the important question has nothing to do with the business that gets the incentive, but rather the overall number of jobs in the region.
We found that the state level incentives (granted only after the jobs are created) resulted in a new manufacturing job for every $1,000 or so of incentives. However, the costs to local government are closer to $30,000 per job.
This prompted a final study on local tax abatements, which found that more liberal use of incentives was associated with higher taxes for other businesses and residents in a county.
We cannot tell for certain if this is because places with high taxes need to incentivize firms or vice versa. Either way, local tax abatements appear to be a costly way to boost the local economy.
Michael J. Hicks, PhD, is the director of the Center for Business and Economic Research and the George and Frances Ball distinguished professor of economics in the Miller College of Business at Ball State University. Hicks earned doctoral and master’s degrees in economics from the University of Tennessee and a bachelor’s degree in economics from Virginia Military Institute.
He has authored two books and more than 60 scholarly works focusing on state and local public policy, including tax and expenditure policy and the impact of Wal-Mart on local economies.
https://commentaries.cberdata.org/708/e ... -abatement
Tax Abatements a Costly Way to Boost Economy
Discussions relating to the hidden cost of Solar and Wind Projects.
Return to “Cost of Solar and Wind Farms”
Jump to
- IMPORTANT INFORMATION
- Communities Fighting Back
- ↳ Dirty Tricks Used by Solar & Wind Developers
- ↳ Winning Strategies
- ↳ Social Media Sites
- ↳ World Wide Groups
- ↳ U.S.A.
- ↳ Alabama
- ↳ Russell County
- ↳ Citizens Against Wind Turbines in Lake Erie
- ↳ Connecticut
- ↳ East Windsor Citizens for Responsible Solar Development
- ↳ Florida
- ↳ Walton County
- ↳ State Wide Info
- ↳ Georgia
- ↳ Illinois
- ↳ Statewide News
- ↳ Champaign County
- ↳ Lee County
- ↳ Piatt County
- ↳ Indiana
- ↳ Indiana State Wide INFO
- ↳ Boone County
- ↳ Cass County IN
- ↳ Decatur County
- ↳ DeKalb County
- ↳ Delaware County
- ↳ Fulton County IN
- ↳ Gibson County
- ↳ Henry County
- ↳ Howard County
- ↳ Jasper County
- ↳ Madison County
- ↳ Marshall County
- ↳ Miami County
- ↳ Montgomery County
- ↳ Posey County
- ↳ Pulaski County
- ↳ Shelby County
- ↳ Spencer County
- ↳ Grandview
- ↳ Troy
- ↳ Sand Ridge & Richland
- ↳ Spencer County News, Facts and Comments
- ↳ Whitley County
- ↳ Iowa
- ↳ Adams County
- ↳ Madison County
- ↳ Union County
- ↳ Kentucky
- ↳ Breckinridge County
- ↳ Massachusetts
- ↳ Bristol County
- ↳ Missouri
- ↳ MoSaysNo
- ↳ Nevada
- ↳ Nye County
- ↳ New York
- ↳ Albany County
- ↳ Columbia County
- ↳ Fulton County
- ↳ Livingston County
- ↳ Montgomery County
- ↳ Niagra County
- ↳ Saratoga County
- ↳ Schenectady County
- ↳ Schoharie County
- ↳ State Wide Info
- ↳ North Carolina
- ↳ Orange County
- ↳ Person County
- ↳ Rowan County Citizens for Responsible Solar
- ↳ Ohio
- ↳ Allen County
- ↳ Auglaize County
- ↳ Darke County
- ↳ Logan County
- ↳ Preble County
- ↳ Union County
- ↳ Warren County
- ↳ Pennsylvania
- ↳ Adams County
- ↳ Residents for Responsible Solar of Mount Joy Township
- ↳ Montour County
- ↳ State Wide
- ↳ Texas
- ↳ Franklin County
- ↳ Hopkins County
- ↳ Jackson County
- ↳ Milam County
- ↳ Virginia
- ↳ Augusta County Solar Project
- ↳ Henrico County
- ↳ Organization For Responsible Solar
- ↳ Page County
- ↳ Spotsylvania County
- ↳ State Wide Info
- ↳ West Virginia
- ↳ Raleigh County
- ↳ Wisconsin
- ↳ Dane County
- ↳ Onion River Project
- ↳ Sheboygan County
- ↳ Wyoming
- ↳ Green River
- ↳ England
- ↳ Chippenham
- ↳ Leigh Delamere
- ↳ East London
- ↳ Newham
- ↳ Hertfordshire
- ↳ Hertsmere
- ↳ Leicestershire
- ↳ Sheffield
- ↳ Suffolk
- ↳ Ipswich
- ↳ Wiltshire
- ↳ Germany
- ↳ National News
- ↳ Ireland
- ↳ Leitrim County
- ↳ State Updates
- ↳ Indiana
- ↳ Websites
- ↳ United Groups
- News Articles
- ↳ Solar and Wind Farm News
- ↳ Bankrupt Solar Companies
- ↳ Environmental Truths
- ↳ General Environmental Comments
- ↳ Batteries as Storage Source
- ↳ Oxygen
- ↳ Toxic Chemicals
- ↳ Videos and Movies
- ↳ Fires
- ↳ Green Energy Costs
- ↳ Land
- ↳ Legal News
- ↳ SEC Filings
- Categories
- ↳ Building Your Own Websites
- ↳ Exposing Developers
- ↳ Exposing The Indivuals
- ↳ Orion Energy Group
- ↳ General Comments
- ↳ General Questions
- ↳ Helping Others
- ↳ How Solar Farms Affected My Life
- ↳ Uniting to Fight Proposed Solar & Wind Projects
- ↳ Hidden Costs of Solar and Wind Farms
- ↳ Cost of Solar and Wind Farms
- ↳ Emotional & Mental Effects of Fighting Solar Farms
- ↳ Health Issues Resulting From Solar and Wind Projects
- ↳ Lawsuits
- ↳ Property Values
- ↳ Solar Companies Out of Business
- ↳ Legal Questions & Comments
- ↳ Attorneys
- ↳ Historical Preservation
- ↳ Lawsuits against Solar
- ↳ Local Regulations
- ↳ Rights of Future Property Owners
- ↳ Political Corruption or Malfeasance
- ↳ Corrupt or Uncaring Federal and State Politicians
- ↳ Corrupt or Uninformed Local Board Meetings
- ↳ Georgia
- ↳ Indiana
- ↳ Spencer County
- ↳ Wisconsin
- ↳ Solar Project Facts
- ↳ Abandoned Solar Farms
- ↳ Deflorestation
- ↳ Neighbors Against Solar Farms
- ↳ Solar Effects on Wildlife & Livestock
- ↳ Solar Energy Information
- ↳ Solar Farm Secrets
- ↳ Solar Frauds
- ↳ Solar Manufactures
- ↳ Solar Panel Fires
- ↳ Solar Panels and Health Effects
- ↳ Solar Panels and Toxic Waste
- ↳ Stop Brainwashing Kids
- ↳ Cut College Funding
- ↳ Non Profits Teaching Lies
- ↳ Stop School Programs
- ↳ Videos
- ↳ Wind Project Facts
- ↳ End of Life Disaster
- ↳ Wind Turbines
- ↳ General Information
- Documents
- ↳ Current Regulations
- ↳ Legal Filings
- ↳ Other Types
- ↳ Regulation Proposals & Questions
- ↳ Solar & Wind Projects
- ↳ Town Board Meetings
- ↳ Legal Documents
- ↳ Good Neighbor Agreements
- ↳ Moratoriums
- ↳ Solar Ordinances
- ↳ Tax Abatements
- Links
- ↳ Other Websites
- ↳ Social Media Groups